View Single Post
  (#18) Old
Vallisk is Offline
ManBat
Vallisk is on a distinguished road
 
Vallisk's Avatar
 
Posts: 1,472
Gallery: 0
Comments: 0
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Cave
Rating: 1 Votes / 5.00 Average
Credits: 47,230
   
02-20-03

Quote:
Originally posted by Necropolis
I want to ask how is it logical?
And does it explain the huge difference between a living person and a newly dead person, if the human body Is just a Organic robot that shuts down then how come they cannot be just turned on again? Or how about the feeling that something that was in the body is no longer there?
We already know that the body is a series of organs, working together to maintain the overall function of the whole. We can point to the Brain and safely say that it contains our memories and our being. Brain injury can change your whole personality, and wipe clean your memories. We don't fully understand it, no, but i do not think anyone would argue that the Brain is not the driving force for our physical bodies and our mental domain.

Now, death to me, means the death of the Brain. Your body can die and be revived, but if the Brain dies it is over for that person. Personality and memories are lost, and the person is reduced to a mass of organic matter. I see no evidence for a soul leaving, merely the failure of the controlling organ.

Some people like to say they have three aspects: physical; mental; and spiritual. I think we have only the first two. The spiritual side is a sub-category of the mental side. Part of what makes us human is our desire to question and seek reason. It is a result of having such a large Brain, capable of complex thought. Every Society is built on our basic need for reason. People do things for a reason, so it must extend outwards and upwards, so that there is a reason for us being here? I think that misses the point. We have the most advanced Brains on the planet. We should use them to investigate the Universe around us, not fall back on to what we would like to be the case.


~As soon as a religion comes to dominate it has as its opponents all those who would have been its first disciples. ~ Nietzsche


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
  
Reply With Quote