"Okay, I see where you're going, Heathen. But consider that if there is a God, and if He is omnipotent, then He can be both just/merciful."
Yes, I can be just and merciful. So can you, big deal. But nothing can be all just and all merciful.

"I know you don't look at it that way, but as a Christian, that's the argument I can present."
That is not an argument. Saying something does not make it true. Arguments have different parts to them. You want to work through them with logic.

I do not wish to drop the subject. I want someone to stop me, or I want to destroy all logic and evidence that any of you think points to any kind of god. When you all fall back soley on faith, or belief without reason (reason as in logic, because fear is a reason for faith), then we can drop this topic.