I enjoyed the movie. The cheesey Star Wars dialogue, the awesome lightsaber fights (they zoomed in a bit close at first, but then they let me see it so I'm happy), the kick-ass spacefights, the darkness of the whole story. It felt like a mature Star Wars, and I was more than happy to welcome it.

I thought that the Wookie battle was too short, as was the fight between Obi-Wan Kenobi and General Grievous (who was an interesting show of things to come with Darth Vader). Also, that ending fight scene and Vader screaming up at Obi-Wan... chilling. It was pretty sweet.

Hacked off hands, hole-fillers for the other ones, hacked off heads, hacked off legs, no Ewoks, and only one Gungan. What's not to like? I was happy as a sci-fi guy can be, I guess.